10 Key Players Projected for Big Rebounds in 2026
Not everyone had a memorable 2025. Many big names will head into the 2026 season with the hope of turning the page after disappointing campaigns. Here's a look at 10 players who could make a significant comeback in the upcoming year.
Alcantara: The Comeback Story
After a challenging 2025 season, where he struggled with effectiveness following Tommy John surgery, Alcantara is poised for a resurgence. FanGraphs predicts a respectable 4.08 ERA and 2.7 WAR over 188 innings, the ninth-highest projected total in MLB. Miami will rely on the 2022 NL Cy Young winner to stabilize its inexperienced rotation, but trade rumors may arise if the team isn't in contention by July. With just one year of team control left after this season, Alcantara's future is a topic of interest.
Betts: Vintage Betts in 2026?
Mookie Betts had a career-low offensive showing in 2025, but the season wasn't a total loss. Despite a strong defensive performance as a full-time shortstop and a solid finish at the plate, Betts still produced 3.4 WAR for the Dodgers. He also earned his fourth World Series ring, enhancing his Hall of Fame credentials. The projections hint at a full-blown return to form for the eight-time All-Star, with a 130 wRC+ and 4.9 WAR, making him one of the top 10 position players in terms of WAR.
Cease: Back on Track
Dylan Cease's performance in 2025 left something to be desired, with his ERA+ dipping below league average for the second time in three years. However, the Blue Jays signed him to a seven-year, $210 million deal, believing in his frontline potential. FanGraphs' projections align with the Blue Jays' evaluation, forecasting a 3.57 ERA, the fourth-most strikeouts, and the 10th-most innings pitched. This indicates a significant improvement from his 2025 mark.
Cruz: Tantalizing Talent
Oneil Cruz's 2025 season was a rollercoaster, with his physical gifts on full display but also swing-and-miss tendencies. Despite hitting 20 homers and stealing 38 bases, Cruz struck out 32% of the time and had a 108 wRC+. With the addition of multiple bats in Pittsburgh, Cruz continues to be a major X-factor. FanGraphs doesn't project him for All-Star numbers, but a 108 wRC+ would be a significant improvement.
Harris: Undisciplined Approach
Harris' undisciplined approach became a hindrance in 2025, with the second-highest chase rate and the lowest walk rate among hitters with at least 500 plate appearances. Despite a strong second half, his 83 wRC+ was a decline for the third straight year. However, the forecast for 2026 is optimistic, predicting 3.5 WAR, a .275/.309/.460 slash, and a 110 wRC+, making him a top prospect for the Braves.
Nola: Back to Form
Aaron Nola, a dependable starter from 2018-24, had a disappointing 2025 season due to injuries. With the Phillies counting on him to get back on track, FanGraphs expects a significant rebound, forecasting a 3.1 WAR and a 4.11 ERA over 180 innings. This improvement is crucial for the team's success.
Pederson: Returning to Form
After a challenging 2025 season with the Texas Rangers, where he missed time with a fractured right hand and had a 76 WRC+, FanGraphs predicts that Pederson will return to his typical level of production. With a projected 118 wRC+, he could significantly boost the team's playoff chances.
Rutschman: Top Catcher in the Game
After a stalled progress in 2025, with a 78 wRC+ in his past 161 games, Rutschman is projected to be a top-five catcher in terms of WAR in 2026, with 19 homers and a 116 wRC+. The Orioles' playoff hopes may depend on internal improvement from their homegrown stars.
Strider: Rebound Year
After a disappointing 2025 season, with a 4.45 ERA and a 9.4 K/9, the Braves will rely on Strider to deliver a strong rebound year. FanGraphs' projections indicate a 3.85 ERA, 187 strikeouts, and 2.8 WAR over 159 innings, putting him closer to his pre-injury form.
Williams: Quantum Leap
Devin Williams, who struggled in the Bronx in 2025, is projected to make a significant leap on the mound. He ranks 11th or better among relievers in projected ERA, K/9, WAR, and saves. Williams' underlying metrics and the Mets' confidence in him make him a key player for the team's success.
